| 1995/96 | |||||||
| 9th Sep | Hinckley Athletic | 1Q | A | 1-3 | 271 | Craig Brookes | Report |
| 1996/97 | |||||||
| 31st Aug | Chester le Street Town | PRE | H | 0-3 | 120 | ||
| 1997/98 | |||||||
| 30th Aug | Whitley Bay | PRE | H | 1-1 | 249 | Paul Kiely | |
| 3rd Sep | Whitley Bay | PREr | A | 3-3 | 180 | Steve Colclough, Paul Kiely, Craig Walklett. (Whitley Bay won 5-3 on penalties) | |
| 1998/99 | |||||||
| 19th Sep | Sutton Coldfield Town | 1Q | A | 1-2 | Scott Dundas | ||
| 1999/2000 | |||||||
| 21st Aug | Wellingborough Town | PRE | A | 0-3 | |||
| 2000/01 | |||||||
| 26th Aug | Pelsall Villa | EP | A | 1-1 | Chris Bermingham | ||
| 29th Aug | Pelsall Villa | EPr | H | 1-3 | Rob Ratcliffe | ||
| 2001/02 | |||||||
| 1st Sep | Arnold Town | PRE | A | 1-4 | Darren Twigg | ||
| 2002/03 | |||||||
| 31st Aug | Buxton | PRE | H | 4-1 | 192 | Steve Tobin 2, Martin MacDonald, Danny Worthington | |
| 14th Sep | Alfreton Town | 1Q | A | 1-0 | 315 | Darren Twigg | |
| 28th Sep | Hinckley United | 2Q | A | 0-3 | 283 | ||
| 2003/04 | |||||||
| 30th Aug | Rugby United | PRE | H | 1-3 | 174 | Darren Twigg | |
| 2004/05 | |||||||
| 4th Sep | Newcastle Town | PRE | H | 1-4 | 281 | Matt Rhead | |
| 2005/06 | |||||||
| 28th Aug | Stourbridge | PRE | A | 2-2 | 218 | Julian Ward, Glyn Hancock | |
| 30th Aug | Stourbridge | PREr | H | 5-2 | 110 | Adam Vickers, Matt Rhead, Julian Ward, Wayne Johnson, Glyn Hancock | |
| 10th Sep | Leamington | 1Q | H | 0-1 | 429 | ||
| 2006/07 | |||||||
| 2nd Sep | Spalding United | PRE | H | 2-0 | 128 | Ian Dawes, Matt Rhead | |
| 16th Sep | Leek Town | 1Q | H | 0-0 | 395 | ||
| 19th Sep | Leek Town | 1Qr | A | 1-0 | 412 | Michael Lennon | |
| 30th Sep | Rothwell Town | 2Q | H | 6-0 | 200 | Matt Rhead 3, Michael Lennon 3 (1 pen) | |
| 14th Oct | Haverhill Rovers | 3Q | A | 1-2 | 669 | Aaron Rey | |
| 2007/08 | |||||||
| 31st Aug | Oldbury United | PRE | A | 3-1 | 74 | Phil Hadland, Michael Lennon 2 | |
| 29th Sep | Willenhall Town | 1Q | H | 2-0 | 127 | Craig Lovatt, Michael Lennon | |
| 2nd Oct | Rainworth Miners Welfare | 2Q | A | 0-2 | 189 | ||
| 2008/09 | |||||||
| 30th Aug | Pilkington XXX | PRE | H | 3-0 | 106 | Jimmy McCarthy, Tom Moss, Andy Matthews | |
| 13th Sep | Eastwood Town | 1Q | A | 0-4 | 230 | ||
| 2009/10 | |||||||
| 29th Aug | Alvechurch | PRE | H | 1-0 | 109 | Dave Walker | |
| 12th Sep | AFC Wulfrunians | 1Q | H | 2-3 | 212 | Ricky Bridge, Matt Haddrell | |
| 2010/11 | |||||||
| 28th Aug | Biddulph Victoria | PRE | H | 0-0 | 168 | ||
| 31st Aug | Biddulph Victoria | PREr | A | 4-0 | 162 | Dave Walker 2, Nick Ward, Tim Sanders | |
| 11th Sep | Chasetown | 1Q | H | 3-0 | 230 | Dave Walker, Liam Shotton, Adam Beasley | |
| 25th Sep | Solihull Moors | 2Q | A | 0-2 | 233 | Report | |
| 2011/12 | |||||||
| 3rd Sep | Atherstone Town | PRE | H | 5-1 | 196 | Dave Walker, Nick Ward, Mark Beeston, Andy Kinsey 2 (1pen) | Report |
| 17th Sep | Gornal Athletic | 1Q | H | 3-0 | 160 | Dave Walker 2 (1 pen), Steve Brannan | Report |
| 1st Oct | Boston United | 2Q | A | 0-0 | 817 | Report | |
| 4th Oct | Boston United | 2Qr | H | 2-0 | 280 | Sam Hall, Craig Dove | Report |
| 15th Oct | Long Buckby | 3Q | H | 2-1 | 343 | Andy Kinsey, Mark Beeston | Report |
| 29th Oct | Bradford (Park Avenue) | 4Q | H | 0-2 | 1140 | ||
| 2012/13 | |||||||
| 25th Aug | AFC Wulfrunians | PRE | A | 0-1 | 100 | Report |